nav emailalert searchbtn searchbox tablepage yinyongbenwen piczone journalimg journalInfo searchdiv qikanlogo popupnotification paper paperNew
2025, 08, v.42 15-21
国产与进口气相色谱仪性能和应用验证评价
基金项目(Foundation):
邮箱(Email): 58594235@qq.com;
DOI: 10.16791/j.cnki.sjg.2025.08.003
摘要:

通过对标进口气相色谱仪,该研究对两家国产气相色谱仪进行了性能指标验证和溶剂残留方法学的应用验证。结果表明国产仪器各项性能指标均能满足要求:基线噪声小于0.05 p A、基线漂移小于0.2 pA、检测限小于5×10–12 g/s、定性和定量重复性分别小于0.2%和1.0%。在此基础上完成了消旋卡多曲化学品中11种残留溶剂的方法学验证对比,结果表明该方法线性关系良好(相关系数r≥0.999)、回收率为95.57%~99.84%、相对标准偏差(RSD)小于3.6%(n=9)。国产气相色谱仪的灵敏度、精密度和准确度等性能与进口设备差异不大,能满足企事业单位的检测要求,高效响应客户需求优于进口设备,但国产仪器工作站的部分参数项需进一步优化。

Abstract:

[Objective] To facilitate the development and application of mid-to-high-end domestic scientific instruments, this study establishes a comprehensive “Domestic Scientific Instrument Verification and Evaluation System” by rigorously assessing the performance validation and practical application. Focusing on gas chromatography technology, comparative evaluations between two domestic gas chromatographs(GCs) and their imported counterparts were conducted. The evaluations encompassed both fundamental performance metrics and methodological validation for residual solvent analysis. This systematic approach promotes technological optimization and accelerates the adoption of domestic analytical instruments in professional laboratories. [Methods] This study systematically evaluated the performance and practical applications of two domestic GCs(FID detectors) compared with their imported counterparts. Performance verification included the testing of carrier gas flow rate, inlet pressure, baseline drift and noise, detection limits, qualitative and quantitative repeatability, and injection carryover. Because current standards lack specifications for the assessment of carrier gas flow rate, this study innovatively implements dual measurement approaches using soap-film and electronic flowmeters. A comparative evaluation revealed that these two domestic GCs exhibited performance metrics comparable to those of their imported counterparts, with all the systems complying with the requirements of national standards(GB/T 30431—2020). In the subsequent practical application validation, Racecadotril, a compound listed in the Chinese Pharmacopoeia(2020 edition), was selected to establish and validate an analytical method for detecting 11 organic solvent residues. The validation covered the parameters of specificity, linearity and range, detection limits, quantitation limits, accuracy, precision, and robustness. The solvent panel comprised 11 compounds, including 3 complex low-concentration analytes(tetrahydrofuran, n-hexane, and isopropyl ether, with concentrations of 0.02%~0.072%). Hence, the panel encompassed the entire concentration range from trace-level to upper-limit specifications and ensured the representativeness of the method. This approach comprehensively assessed the key performance characteristics of domestic instruments, including sensitivity, accuracy, methodological validity, and operational feasibility. Therefore, the evaluation provided definitive evidence of the instruments' compliance with stringent standards for analytical methods. [Results] Both domestic GCs satisfied all performance requirements. Their performance was comparable to that of the imported counterparts, i.e., they demonstrated the following parameters: baseline noise <0.05 pA, baseline drift <0.2 pA, detection limit <5×10-12 g/s, qualitative and quantitative repeatability <0.2% and 1.0%, respectively, with excellent flow rate accuracy and stability, and injection carryover <0.1%. Comprehensive method validation for the 11 residual solvents in Racecadotril demonstrated excellent performance characteristics, with the following observed values: linear regression correlation(r≥0.999, n=6 calibration points), mean recovery of 95.57%–99.84% across three spike levels, intermediate precision(RSD<3.6%, n=9), and LOQ precision(RSD<7.0%). This optimized protocol provided simple, accurate, and precise simultaneous quantification, with domestic GCs exhibiting superior performance in detecting low-abundance solvents compared to the imported counterparts. [Conclusions] Modern domestic GCs comply with all applicable national standards(GB/T 30431—2020) and offer distinct competitive advantages, including superior technical support responsiveness and operator-centric interfaces featuring Mandarin-optimized workflow designs. Although the workstation software for these instruments requires further optimization for advanced data processing(particularly concerning multivariate analysis and custom reporting functions), the fundamental analytical capabilities of the instruments demonstrate parity with those of the imported counterparts. These findings provide a robust foundation for ongoing quality assessment and support the strategic adoption of domestic instruments. Future studies need to focus on evaluations for long-term reliability to complete the verification paradigm and facilitate the transition to domestic analytical instrumentation in professional laboratories.

参考文献

[1]张浩钰.气相色谱法在我国食品药品质量检测技术中的应用[J].现代食品, 2021(16):53–55.ZHAN H Y. Application of gas chromatography in food and drug quality detection technology in China[J]. Modern Food,2021(16):53–55.(in Chinese)

[2]武晨箫,黄晓伟.我国科技自立自强道路研究[J].理论视野,2023(1):65–71.WU C X, HUANG X W. Research on the path of self-reliance in science and technology in China[J]. Theoretical Perspective,2023(1):65–71.(in Chinese)

[3]杨丽,岳琦,类淑霞,等.我国大型质谱仪器发展现状与展望[J].实验技术与管理, 2024, 41(7):1–8.YANG L, YUE Q, LEI S X, et al. Development status and prospects of large mass spectrometry instruments in China[J].Experimental Technology and Management, 2024, 41(7):1–8.(in Chinese)

[4]孙占久,王超,吕晶淼.促进国产科研仪器发展的策略研究[J].实验室研究与探索, 2022, 41(6):296–300.SUN Z J, WANG C, LU J M. Research on strategies to promote the development of domestic scientific instruments[J]. Research and Expolration in Laboratory, 2022, 41(6):296–300.(in Chinese)

[5]靳凤民,张丽娜,徐振国,等.国产科学仪器研究及应用示范中心的探索与实践[J].实验技术与管理, 2024, 41(11):240–244.JIN F M, ZHANG L N, XU Z G, et al. Exploration and practice of the Domestic Scientific Instrument Research and Application Demonstration Center[J]. Experimental Technology and Management,2024, 41(11):240–244.(in Chinese)

[6]韩凤芹,陈亚平.我国科研仪器进口依赖的原因分析与对策建议[J].世界科技研究与发展, 2022, 44(3):314–321.HAN F Q, CHEN Y P. Analysis and countermeasures of import dependence of scientific instruments of China[J]. World Sci-Tech R&D, 2022, 44(3):314–321.(in Chinese)

[7]岳琦,赵长征,韩玉刚,等.我国进口科研仪器维修维护发展现状与趋势[J].实验技术与管理, 2024, 41(7):9–14.YUE Q, ZHAO C Z, HAN Y G, et al. Current situation and trend of imported scientific instrument repair in China[J].Experimental Technology and Management, 2024, 41(7):9–14.(in Chinese)

[8]张小萌,王益民.高校教学科研用仪器设备国产化研究[J].实验室研究与探索, 2017, 36(6):291–294.ZHANG X M, WANG Y M. A Study of localization of teaching and research equipment in colleges and universities[J]. Research and Expolration in Laboratory, 2017, 36(6):291–294.(in Chinese)

[9]解静,刘鑫,高峰.开展权威验证评价工作,为国产仪器保驾护航[J].分析仪器, 2019(4):98–101.XIE J, LIU X, GAO F. Verificaiton and evaluation on domestic scientific instruments by authority[J]. Analytical Instrumentation,2019(4):98–101.(in Chinese)

[10]袁勇,张燕勤,付国春,等.新时期新质生产力赋能科学仪器“国产替代”[J].实验技术与管理, 2024, 41(9):1–6.YUAN Y, ZHANG Y Q, FU G C, et al. New quality productivity in the new era enabling scientific instruments“domestic substitution”[J]. Experimental Technology and Management,2024, 41(9):1–6.(in Chinese)

[11]朱凤昌,崇小萌,杨青,等. ICH Q3C残留溶剂指导原则与中国药典残留溶剂控制策略[J].中国医药工业杂志, 2021,52(9):1259–1262.ZHU F C, CHONG X M, YANG Q, et al. ICH Q3C guideline and Chinese pharmacopoeia control strategy for residual solvents[J]. Chinese Journal of Pharmaceuticals, 2021, 52(9):1259–1262.(in Chinese)

[12]伍伟聪,林嗣翔,郭雅娟,等.基于ICH Q3C协调的《中华人民共和国药典》药用辅料果胶标准中残留溶剂控制[J].医药导报, 2025, 44(2):235–238.WU W C, LIN S X, GUO Y J, et al. Research on residual solvent control of pectin standard for pharmaceutical excipients in the Chinese Pharmacopoeia based on ICH Q3C coordination[J].Herald of Medicine, 2025, 44(2):235–238.(in Chinese)

[13]顾璇,李灿,崔艳华,等.顶空进样-气相色谱法同时测定维生素D滴剂中12种溶剂残留[J].化学分析计量, 2024, 33(5):6–11.GU X, LI C, CUI Y H, et al. Simultaneous determination of 12solvent residues in vitamin D drops by headspace injection gas chromatography[J]. Chemical Analysis and Meterage, 2024,33(5):6–11.(in Chinese)

[14]周冉,王飞,林佳睿,等.顶空-气相色谱法测定伊班膦酸钠中多种残留溶剂[J].色谱, 2024, 42(5):481–486.ZHOU R,WANG F,LIN J R,et al. Determination of multiple residual solvents in Ibandronate Sodium using headspace-gas chromatography[J]. Chinese Journal of Chromatography, 2024,42(5):481–486.(in Chinese)

[15]宋小飞,王红芳,宋素丽,等.顶空进样-气相色谱法同时测定磷酸芦可替尼中13种溶剂[J].化学分析计量, 2025, 34(1):93–99.SONG X F, WANG H F, SONG S L, et al. Simultaneous determination of 13 solvents in Ruxolitinib Phosphate by headspace injection gas chromatography[J]. Chemical Analysis and Meterage, 2025, 34(1):93–99.(in Chinese)

[16]樊成,魏宁果,范芳芳.国产与进口气相色谱仪在白酒分析中的比较研究[J].酿酒科技, 2024(2):110–115.FANG C, WEI N G, FAN F F. Comparison of domestic and imported gas chromatographs in the analysis of baijiu[J].Liquor-Making Science&Technology, 2024(2):110–115.(in Chinese)

[17]邓雅美,王秀军.气相色谱法测定舒林酸中的残留溶剂[J].广东化工, 2024, 51(24):128–131.DENG Y M, WANG X J. Determination of residual solvents in sulindac by gas chromatography[J]. Guangdong Chemical Industry,2024, 51(24):128–131.(in Chinese)

[18]肖志偲,覃琳,徐燕,等,气相色谱法测定溴夫定原料药中溶剂残留量[J].食品与药品, 2025, 27(2):164–169.XIAO Z S, TAN L, XU Y, et al. Determination of residual solvents in brivudine API by gas chromatography[J]. Food and Drug, 2025, 27(2):164–169.(in Chinese)

基本信息:

DOI:10.16791/j.cnki.sjg.2025.08.003

中图分类号:TH833

引用信息:

[1]汪杰,王李杰,葛道至,等.国产与进口气相色谱仪性能和应用验证评价[J].实验技术与管理,2025,42(08):15-21.DOI:10.16791/j.cnki.sjg.2025.08.003.

基金信息:

检 索 高级检索

引用

GB/T 7714-2015 格式引文
MLA格式引文
APA格式引文